Creepy Halloween Recipes

Find Creepy Halloween Recipes. These fun and easy ideas are perfect for a kids party at Halloween. Delicious party food decorated with the spooky themes of the season. Children love a good Halloween snack recipe and now you've found a great source of them. You will even find a tasty punch recipe and this punch is one of those creepy Halloween recipes...you will see why when you read it.



These recipes are easy to make, and some are scary and creepy...but it's all in good fun. The recipes here are perfect to use at a holiday get together or a costume party. You can even make some Halloween main dish recipes to surprise your kids! Imagine how thrilled they will be when they see the treats and main dishes you have made for them. I'll bet they want to help you make dinner the next day!

Submit your scary food recipes and see more of our ideas at the bottom of the page


Brains on the Half Skull...Halloween Main Dish Recipes

Brains on the Half Skull is one of a couple creepy Halloween recipes and it's a main dish. It's really spagetti served in a half of a potato skin. It tastes just like spagetti, but it's serving dish lends something special to the Halloween mood!

Here's an easy Halloween recipe to serve to your children before they head out to trick or treat. Get them into a haunted mood with this gross recipe.

Here are the ingredients for you gross Halloween recipe ideas:

  • 2 medium-sized potatoes
  • 1 8 oz. package thin spaghetti
  • 1 14 oz jar or can of spaghetti sauce

Here's how to prepare your gross dinner idea:

  • Preheat oven to 400 degrees Fahrenheit
  • Wash the potatoes and cut them in half lengthwise.
  • Place potatoes, cut side up, on a baking dish.
  • Bake for 40 minutes.
  • As the potatoes bake, boil a pot of water and cook the spagetti to your desired tenderness.
  • Drain the spagetti
  • Prepare your spagetti sauce by heating it up just a few minutes before the potatoes will be ready.
  • Take your potatoes out of the oven.
  • Cut your potatoes in half.
  • Scoop the insides out of each potatoe half.
  • These skins will become your "skulls" so keep them intact.
  • When the sauce is heated, remove it from the stove and pour it into the spagetti.
  • These are your brains.
  • Fill each of the empty potatoe skins with some spagetti....there's your bloody brains in a skull.
  • Just serve it up now.
  • (What do you do with the potatoes you just baked if you are not going to use anything but the potatoe skin? Just save your potatoes for tomorrow night's dinner!)
  • To make more than four servings, add 1 potatoe for each two servings. When you add an extra potatoe or two, be sure to increase the amount of spagetti and sauce you prepare


Halloween Party Games Pack: over 50 printables for all the family!



Cheesy Eyeballs One Of The Scary Halloween Recipes

Cheesy Eyeballs are from the Creepy Halloween Recipes collection. Scary Eyeballs are always a gross Halloween food recipe that's a hit! This is an easy Halloween party appetizer idea that is fun to make, eat and just look at!

Your Cheesey Eyeball ingredients are:

  • Salt-1/2 teaspoon

  • Hungarian sweet paprika-1 teaspoon
  • All-purpose flour-1 cup
  • Shredded cheddar cheese-2 cups
  • Very cold butter-1 stick cut into small cubes
  • small pimento-stuffed green olives-24 of them

Here's how to put together your gory, scary eyeball recipe:

  • In a bowl put your salt, paprika and flour.
  • Whisk the ingredients and set the bowl to the side.
  • Put the butter and the cheddar cheese in a food processor that is fitted with a metal blade.
  • Turn it on and pour the flour mixture into the foot chute very SLOWLY.
  • Stop as soon as all the ingredients are combined.
  • Do not over process.
  • Finally, let's make those gross eyeball appetizers.
  • Using a teaspoon, take spoonfuls of the cheesy mixture and wrap it around an olive so the pimento is looking out of the circle.
  • There's your eyeball and your pupil.
  • Put it onto a baking sheet and continue until all your cheese mix is gone.
  • Make sure to put them on the sheet with the pimento end (the eyeball) looking up!
  • Keep refrigerated for at least 60 minutes or even as long as overnight.
  • Bake according to directions below.
If you want to prepare this gross Halloween recipe, you can make it ahead and then freeze your cheesy eyeballs. When you put them into the freezer, let them sit on a tray. When they are frozen, take them and place them into freezer bags. Take them out and let them defrost when you are ready to bake them! Now, right before you serve your cheesy Halloween eyeball appetizers:
  • Preheat your overn to 40 degrees F.
  • Put some parchment paper on a baking sheet.
  • Bake cheesy eyeballs for 15 minutes.
  • Serve your Halloween eyeballs warm.
This recipe makes about two dozen gross, scary Halloween cheesy eyeballs. Make a label for this creepy Halloween recipe...put something that has to do with eyes on it, like The Better To See You With!

Find more creepy Halloween recipes!


Submit Your Own Scary Recipes

Do You Have Any Really Creepy Halloween Recipes To Scare Your Halloween Party Guests?

If you have any delicious but Creepy Halloween Recipes, share them with us! Scary Halloween recipes are half the fun of a Halloween party...the other half is the fun games and the costumes!

If you are planning a costume party for October 31st make sure you've got some scary food ideas...body parts are always gross...and plan lots of fun games. Some of the games can also include some creepy Halloween recipes so you might have to double up a recipe or two.

Take pictures of your creepy food dishes and let us see how they looked! Tell us how you made them and then take a look at the recipes we made so you can add them to your Halloween recipe book.

We have a couple different Eyeball recipes, a few Brain recipes that you make in a brain mold and there are also some finger cookie recipes...plus some gory dips and spooky witch and goblin punch recipes.

Learn how to make some scary ice to serve at your costume party. Ice cubes with bugs, ice cubes that look like eyeballs and ice cubes shaped like vampire fangs...have fun with food on Halloween using our gross, creepy recipes.

Gross, Scary, Spooky, Frightfully delicious recipes for appetizers, punch and drinks, main courses and desserts for some super scary eats at your costume party!


See New And Fun Halloween Ideas On The Blog

Go from Creepy Halloween Recipes to Party Ideas Parade Home



Custom Search


Top | Home | Halloween Costumes | Kids Party Ideas | Cupcake Ideas | Pinatas | Party Favors | Halloween Masks | Holiday Party Ideas | Halloween Party Supplies | Supply Catalogs | Coloring Pages | Contact Party Ideas | Twilight Party | Party Games | Party Recipes | Party Ideas Blog

The Perfect Costume



Looking for the Perfect Costume?


Pumpkin Carving Stencils | Hundreds to choose from





BuyCostumes.com Product Videos






Fun Printable Halloween Games

Halloween Party Games Pack: over 50 printables for all the family!






Halloween Hand Mold!

Scary Food Ideas For Your Halloween Party. Hand Gelatin Mold